A05: Proposal+10 skyblue

Elephants are beautiful wild animals that many humans adore. We go to zoo’s [zoos] and circuses to admire the huge graceful animals. While admiring these animals[,] the public is [we are] not told of the severe torture that elephants are put through in capturing them from the wild and when training them for captivity. For my essay, I will research different ways elephants are abused and tortured, something circus and zoo owners try to keep hidden from the public. While doing this I will unveil how detrimental this abuse is to the elephant wildlife, inching them closer [and closer to being extinct] [to extinction]. It is [an] extremely counterintuitive [topic] that we adore and admire the beauty of this endangered animal, but continue to support the abuse by going to circus shows or the zoo.

1. Ringling Bros. – Elephant Child Abusers — Breaking a Baby Elephant

Background: This video is broken down into the different steps it takes to captivate an elephant and turn it into a domestic animal for the pure benefit of the entertainment business. The first step includes acquiring a baby elephant, which is done by importing asian elephants by [bounding] [binding] their legs together. Now that the Endangered Species Act has been passed[,] Ringling Bros has [their] [its] own farm to breed elephants in Florida. [The] second step is to take the babies from the mothers immediately after birth. They “break” [wild] elephants [because they are wild] and [need to be tamed] [tame them] for the circus. The third step is to tie up all four legs of the baby elephant and keep it isolated for 23 hours a day. Step four is teaching the elephant circus tricks using ropes, bull hooks, and electronic prods.

How I Plan On Using It: The circus is a place that most associate with happiness and fun entertainment. Few [of us] [people] know what the process of training the elephants is like and it is hidden [for the sole reason being people will frown upon it] [because it is disgraceful]. I will use this source to expose the Ringling Bros. [circus] for [its] [how they treat and train their] [disgraceful treatment of] elephants.

2. Elephant Tusks

Background: This article explains what elephant tusks are, why they are so crucial to the [elephants] [elephants’] lives, and why and how people are retrieving these tusks. Elephants use their tusks to protect themselves[,] [;] without them their lives are at risk from [other] predators such as lions and tigers. Their tusks are the main reason elephants are being heavily hunted[,] [;] they are used for pianos, billiard balls and sometimes for pride of [possessing them] [possession].

Use It: I will use this specific source as [another view on how] [evidence that] elephants are being abused and hunted. Without their tusks[,] it is difficult for elephants to survive, [in the end creating a more immense] [further endangering an already] endangered species.

3. 6 Ways To Help Elephants

Background: This [cite] [source] provides six easy ways [that] humans can [do to help] protect and save elephants from extinction. [Some] [They] include avoiding circuses and zoos, [and] being aware of where [your] [our] coffee is from because some plantations destroy elephant’s habitat.

Use It: This source will be an excellent way to provide diversity to my paper. It gives hope and allows the reader to see a solution for the argument being posted.

4. Get Elephants Out of Zoos

Background: [Elephant’s] [Elephants’] living conditions in zoos are much more condensed [then] [than] [they are used to living] in the wild. [It talks about the pitiful standards that zoos need to keep][Living standards for] an elephant[,] such as 20 feet by 20 feet of space [for an elephant] [per animal], [are pitiful]. This eliminates the elephant’s nature to roam and walk freely as it does in the wild. It also exposes the forceful way [elephants are bred] [zoos breed elephants,] mostly through artificial insemination, knowing that most [of the outcomes are] [pregnancies will end in] miscarriages or dead baby elephants. Overall, it exposes all the hideous truths [that go into] [about] keeping an elephant at a zoo.

Use It: [Other than] [In addition to] circuses, zoos are also guilty [when it comes to] [of] mistreating their elephants. [Using] This [cite] [source] strengthens my argument [of abusive tendencies towards elephants] [that elephants are abused], [while providing a variety of places] [and identifies where] they get abused.

5. Cruelest Show on Earth

Background: The article revolves around a [young three year old] [three-year-old] elephant named Kenny[. Kenny], [who] became very sick during a show on tour. Sickly elephants require prompt medical care to [make sure that they are able to preform to the best of their abilities][insure their best performance]. [What seems like a safe and intelligent precaution is where it goes south. Kenny was observed and the veterinarian recommended that Kenny skip the evening show that night.] Ringling Bros ignored [this request] [a reasonable suggestion by the veterinarian that Kenny skip one show], and forced Kenny to [preform] [perform] even though he was deathly sick and incredibly [week] [weak]. That night Kenny died [as he was] shackled [to] [in] his suffocatingly small pen.

Use It: This shows the carelessness of the elephant trainers and circus workers. This article provides a story of a specific elephant Kenny which gives a more personal [connect] [connection] with readers and provokes a stronger reaction.

6. Ringling Bros. Eliminating Elephant Acts

Background: Ringling Bros. are phasing out elephants from their acts by 2018. The elephants that are in their shows will be sent to the Center for Elephant Conservation after they are eliminated from the acts.

Use It: This proves that the elephants are being mistreated and that [they] [Ringling Bros.] are finally acknowledging the misuse. For a long time they ignored or hid the fact that they mistreated the elephants and this is proof that they now recognize their wrong doings.

7. Poachers Target African Elephant for Ivory Tusks

Background: This article goes into depth about the rising crisis of ivory smuggling in the past few years. Several tons of ivory tusks are being smuggled and sold[,] [;] poachers do this to make a profit because ivory is rare and pricey. It also discusses that the poachers are killing elephants at “massacre sites” and [only taking] [taking only] their tusks, no meat from the elephant.

Use It: This article strengthens my first source on elephant tusks and provides a more detailed depiction of the actual tons of ivory that [is] [are] being smuggled. This also backs up my argument on elephant abuse because it talks about poachers killing elephants solely for their tusks.

8. Elephant Abuse

Background: It talks about how in most zoos throughout the country elephants are chained up in a confined area and beaten. They explain the reason most zoos beat the elephants is to “keep the elephants in check” and to show that the elephant handler is dominant over the huge animal. This source offers a different perspective because it explains how the Oakland Zoo uses positive reinforcement like treats to train their elephants without abuse, and they also give the animals plenty of space to roam.

Use It: This goes along with my argument [and how] [that] training elephants is more like torturing them, and that there has to be [another way to get the point across] [a better method]. The Oakland Zoo [gives that option of] [uses] positive reinforcement and [treating] [treats] elephants correctly, and still [getting] [gets] them to do what trainers want them to do.

9. Elephant Abuse at Zoo Leads to Lawsuit

Background: This source is about a lawsuit that was filed against Woodland Park Zoo in Seattle, Washington. It explains the harsh [realities of][treatment] elephants [go through when living][suffer] in zoos, [including] [The elephants suffer from] chronic pains in their feet and joints from standing on hard cement surfaces all day long. They are also ripped from their mothers and [artificial] [artificially] inseminated multiple times even though most [pregnancies] end [up] in miscarriages.

Use It: I will use this source to shine light on the abuse that goes on in zoos as well as circuses. It provides the proof that zoo owners do not want the public to know about elephants in zoos.

10. The Death of Stony the Elephant

Background: Stony was a circus elephant who was practicing standing on his two hind legs when his hamstring exploded. Stony was then brought to quarters where he was kept laying in his own waste unable to move a whole lot. He then died before they could send him off to an elephant breeding facility

Use It: This is another instance that [makes] [strengthens] my case about elephant abuse in circuses [stronger]. It also shows the [lack of attention designated to elephants that are injured] [neglect of injured elephants], and the strong need to breed as many elephants as possible. [That is shown by wanted to send] [It tells the story of a zoo that sent] an [mobile] [immobile,] injured elephant to [an elephant] [a] breeding farm.

This entry was posted in X Archive. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to A05: Proposal+10 skyblue

  1. skybluecomp2's avatar skybluecomp2 says:

    feedback was requested
    Feedback provided. —DSH

    Like

  2. davidbdale's avatar davidbdale says:

    Skyblue, you’re a clear thinker, so you’re capable of clear writing, but you get in your own way. Readers will always be confused until you say exactly what you mean. Here are examples.

    Elephants are thought of as beautiful wild animals that many humans adore. We go to zoo’s and circuses to admire the huge graceful animals. What people do not realize when admiring these animals is the severe torture that they are put through in both the wild and in training themfor captivity.

    For my essay, I will research different ways elephants are abused and tortured while remaining hidden from the public. While doing this I will unveil how detrimental this abuse is to the endangered elephant wildlife. If we as a public adore and admire the beauty of this endangered animal why do we let the abuse continue, or even encourage it by going to circus shows or the zoo.

    thought of as
    They either are or they aren’t beautiful and adored. You want to claim that they are. Saying that they “are thought of . . . ” is the equivalent of saying: “people have the odd notion that . . . .”

    people do not realize
    Your point is not merely that people are unaware (sharing the blame by not wanting to know), but that the abuse is being hidden. You want to call this the dirty secret of elephant shows.

    in both the wild and in training them
    both . . . and pairs must be parallel. Yours tries to combine a place (the wild) with an activity (training). Readers expecting another place get confused.

    while remaining hidden from the public
    Here your phrase modifies the most likely subject: you. It accidentally says that you will remain hidden while you do your investigation.

    how detrimental this abuse is to the endangered
    This conflates two very separate complaints into one. The abuse is unfortunate of course, but not because the species is endangered. However, if the abuse contributes to the species’ endangerment, then of course you should say that.

    If
    You’ve established that we do love elephants. Don’t cast doubt on that now. You could claim that our love does not seem helpful to them. It’s certainly counterintuitive that we visit them out of love in places that do them harm. We’re kept from knowing the harm, remember, so we harm them unknowingly (and we wouldn’t if we knew because we love them). Keep that central idea alive.

    as a public
    Weird. If “we” can’t act as a private, we probably can’t act as a public either. But either way, try not to separate yourself from your readers. Help them with the information, don’t chastise them for not knowing something you learned first.

    why do we let the abuse continue
    You’ve explained to us that we don’t know about the abuse, so we’re not “letting it continue” at all. Now, once you fully inform us, you can appeal to us to help bring the abuse to an end. But always as we. Now that we know, we must end this abuse.

    by going to circus shows or the zoo
    . . . assuming every parent who takes a kid to the zoo believes the animals are being mistreated. Otherwise, what would make them think so? Life in the wild is tough; here they are protected and fed and have a personal vet.

    I’ll save comments on content for the White Paper, skyblue, if that’s OK with you. I think I’ve done enough damage here already.

    Is this helpful? Too intrusive? Too demanding?
    Awaiting your reply.

    Like

  3. skybluecomp2's avatar skybluecomp2 says:

    I really appreciate all your feedback, by giving an example of where I went wrong and explaining it helps me understand it better. I will go back and fix what you’ve proposed. Thank you very much for your time and input.

    Like

  4. skybluecomp2's avatar skybluecomp2 says:

    I’ve read through all your comments individually and went back and looked through my work to see that you are right, and simple wording could throw the meaning off. This is my rewrite for Wednesday! Thank you for your time and awesome feedback!

    Like

  5. skybluecomp2's avatar skybluecomp2 says:

    feedback requested

    Feedback provided. —DSH

    Like

  6. davidbdale's avatar davidbdale says:

    Good to be back!
    P1. This is much better, skyblue. You appear reluctant to embrace the first person plural, though, even when you’re writing about a personal passion. Your first three sentences waver from “many humans” to “we” to “the public.” You’re not afraid of the first person, clearly; sentence 4 contains “I,” but then goes back to “the public.” Can you articulate your reluctance?

    What would you like to do next, skyblue?
    1. Examine the intended uses you’ll put your sources to?
    2. Take a close look at the grammar and punctuation errors that will spoil even your best work if they’re not addressed before the portfolio?

    Like

  7. skybluecomp2's avatar skybluecomp2 says:

    I would like to narrow in on my grammar and punctuation errors to prevent me from spoiling any future papers or assignments. As always, thank you for your time.

    Like

  8. davidbdale's avatar davidbdale says:

    OK, with your permission, I’ll mark up your text directly with corrections and improvements. I’ll trust you to learn from the changes and catch your own troubles in future. OK?
    Awaiting your reply.

    Like

Leave a comment