Safe Saws — skyblue

Posted on March 4, 2015 by skybluecomp2
  • 6A: “Every year, thousands of people are severely injured after using table saws.”
  • 6B: That thousands of people are consistently injured at a rate of thousands per year. We are not sure if they are using the saws in a correct manner. They claim that users are injured after they use the saw, not during. They could have been doing any activity when they got injured after using the saw.
  • 6C: The claim is a causal claim, it claims that the users are getting injured by using the table saws.
  • 6D: The first claim, “every year” is not accurate or reasonable because it is necessary that the people must be injured by table saws every year
    • the second claim “Thousands of people” is alson not accurate because that number must stay consistant every year and that is not proven.
    • Third claim, “severely injured” is illogical because it claims that all of the thousands are severely injured and not injured in a minor way.
    • The fourth claim, that users are injured “after using table saws” This is completely inaccurate and not valid. The claim does not have anything to do with the use of the table saw, but focuses on after the use.
  • 6E: I would dispute that they claim users are being injured “after” using the table saws, this could mean a number of different things. The users could be injured doing anything not involving the table saw after they have finished using the saw.
This entry was posted in X Archive. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a comment